Average Rent in Eltingville, Staten Island
The median rent in Eltingville, Staten Island is $4,425/month as of February 2026, based on 1 listings.
Rent by Bedroom Size
| Beds | Budget (10th) | Median | High-End (90th) | Listings |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 Bedrooms | $4,425 | $4,425 | $4,425 | 1 |
About Eltingville
Two-bedroom apartments in Eltingville clock in at a surprising $4,425/month, reflecting this South Shore gem's sought-after suburban feel and excellent schools. If you're prioritizing space and a quieter community over borough-hopping, Eltingville offers a compelling value proposition for families.
How Eltingville Compares
A 1-bedroom in Eltingville is 126% above the Staten Island median.
Frequently Asked Questions
- What is the average rent in Eltingville?
- The median rent for a one-bedroom apartment in Eltingville, Staten Island is $4,425 per month based on current market data.
- Is Eltingville expensive compared to Staten Island?
- Yes, Eltingville is 126% above the Staten Island median of $1,955/month for a one-bedroom.
- How do I find affordable apartments in Eltingville?
- Set up a Leaseswap alert for Eltingville with your budget. We monitor new listings across major platforms and notify you within minutes when a matching apartment is posted.
Get Alerts for Eltingville
Prices move fast in Eltingville. Get notified within minutes when a new listing matches your budget.
Create a Free Alert