Sutton Place, Manhattan

238 East 58th Street

A 22-unit mid-rise built in 1904 in Sutton Place, Manhattan. We've seen 6 listings here since April 2026, with a one-bedroom asking a median of $4,200.
  • Built 1904
  • 22 units
  • Rent-stabilized units on record
  • Updated July 2026
1 bedroom ask
$4,200
median
Listings seen
6
since Apr 2026
Stabilized units
6
12 in 2007
HPD violations
18
last 12 months
Asking rents

What apartments at 238 East 58th Street ask

Median asking rent by size across 6 listings seen between April 2026 and July 2026. From public rental listings Leaseswap tracks on StreetEasy, NYBits, LeaseBreak and others. Asking rents, not signed leases.

  • 1 bedroom$4,200$4,2002 listings
  • 2 bedrooms$4,950$4,600 to $6,2004 listings
Rent stabilization

Rent-stabilized units on record

Unit counts from NYC tax records, via JustFix's Who Owns What.

Latest

6

In 2007

12

Units

22

This means the building has rent-stabilized units, not that every apartment in it is stabilized or carries a legal rent. Always check a unit's status and rent history with DHCR before signing a lease.

Building conditions

18 HPD violations in the last 12 months

Housing code violations issued by NYC HPD, by class. Data as of July 27, 2026.

Class C

9

Immediately hazardous

Class B

6

Hazardous

Class A

2

Non-hazardous

11 open violations · 16 complaints in 12 months · 0 eviction filings in 12 months

Ownership

Who owns the building

From NYC HPD registration records, via JustFix's Who Owns What. Company names only.

Owner
Brighton Management
Portfolio
45 buildings · 953 units
Last sale
November 7, 2021
Features

What listings here mention

Building features that most listings at this address report.

Ready to act

Get alerts for Sutton Place.

Prices move fast in Sutton Place. Get notified within minutes when a new listing matches your budget.

Create a free alert
Nearby

More buildings in Sutton Place

FAQs

Common questions

Is 238 East 58th Street rent-stabilized?
NYC tax records list 6 rent-stabilized units at 238 East 58th Street (12 in 2007). That means the building has rent-stabilized units, not that every apartment in it is stabilized. Confirm a specific unit's status and rent history with DHCR before signing a lease.
How much is rent at 238 East 58th Street?
Across 6 public rental listings Leaseswap tracks on StreetEasy, NYBits, LeaseBreak and others between April 2026 and July 2026, median asking rents were $4,200 for a one-bedroom, $4,950 for a two-bedroom. These are asking rents from listings, not signed leases.
Who owns 238 East 58th Street?
NYC HPD registration records link 238 East 58th Street to Brighton Management, which is associated with 45 buildings and 953 units in NYC. Ownership data comes from JustFix's Who Owns What.
How many HPD violations does 238 East 58th Street have?
HPD issued 18 violations at 238 East 58th Street in the last 12 months, including 9 class C (immediately hazardous), and 11 are currently open. Data as of July 27, 2026.